The launching of the 37th volume of the Haigazian Armenological Review

1345

An Armenological Repository

Today more than ever Armenians are dispersed, and there are institutions and units of varying organizational capacity in some 120 countries. Due to their worldwide dispersal, as well as globalization and other factors, Armenians are involved in an unprecedented manner in international economic, political, cultural, artistic, social, scientific, communications and state affairs around the world.

Therefore, today more then ever, it is impotant to amalgamate, systematize and categorize the increasingly diverse and scattered creative output of the Armenian people.

For instance, one may mention the fact that today in some 50 countries Armenian-language and/or Armenian-related books are being published. But these publications do not have a common gathering place where one can search and choose the book one likes.

To be more specific, many books are being published in different places in the field of Armenian studies. Research centers organize conferences and publish their proceedings. Periodicals of Armenology and other fields publish a large number of research papers and archival materials on Armenian-related matters. Several Armenian studies topics have attracted renewed interest. Both the number of non-Armenian experts and the languages in which they write their Armenian-related papers have increased. Interdisciplinary communication is more than ever diverse and easy. Armenian studies have become multidisciplinary. The sphere of Armenian studies is growing horizontally more than vertically.

These developments, however, have not resolved some old concerns of Armenian studies. Rather, they have added new challenges to existing difficulties and raised new issues, creating further complications. For instance, today it is hard to accumulate adequate, comprehensive information and knowledge on any particular Armenian topic that has previously been researched. Existing bibliographies of periodicals and books, as well as archival lists, are localized and at times partial, and thus are far from being complete and all-encompassing. Current researchers have access only to incomplete information on the sources that exist on specific topics, and when, where and by whom they have been published.

Today, when technological and methodological innovations enable Armenian studies to flourish and help to elevate the field to a qualitatively new level, the existence of an online Armenian studies repository, where all kinds of published materials — books, articles, review papers, research and archival materials — will be stored and categorized, is more than ever essential.

Discussion of the details of this Armemonological repository seems of secondary importance at this stage. What is of utmost importance, however, is its immediate initiation with pan-Armenian support and efforts, through the active participation of academic, research, and cultural institutions of the Diaspora and the Republic of Armenia.

In the 18th century, Armenian studies made an important contribution to the development of Armenian self-perception, national identity and the reconstruction of the Armenian character. These developments and the Armenian revival that they triggered were mainly due to the efforts of the Mekhitarist congregation, who alongside other tasks, gathered Armenian sources and studied them in a coordinated manner. In the second half of the 20th century, the Armenian National Academy of Sciences and the Matenadaran in particular deepened and systematized the study of Armenological topics, elevating the discipline to new heights. Indeed, Armenian studies became a strong factor impacting and orienting national life .

Today, Armenian studies should give new impetus to Armenian spiritual and cultural revival, and once again play a significant role in the development of a pan-national psychology, the consolidation of national unity, and the strenghtening of national commitment to a titular nation.

The gathering and systematic classification of Armenian studies materials were the main objective factors that triggered the advancement of Armenian studies with new strength and power in the past. There is no doubt that assembling all Armenian studies materials on an online platform will not only preserve their legacy but will also generate renewed interest in and further growth of the field.

All should support efforts to ensure the realization of the Armenological repository, and its successful use, growth and sustainability.

EDITOR-IN-CHIEF

The Very Rev. Father Antranik Granian

EDTORIAL BOARD

Antranik Dakessian (executive secretary) – Arda Ekmekji (ex-officio) – Arshalouyse Topalian – Armen Urneshlian – Nanor Karageozian (ex-officio)

CONSULTATIVE BODY

Sylvia Agemian – Megerditch H. Bouldoukian – Seta B. Dadoyan – Murad Hasratian – Hranush Kharatian – Susan Pattie – Jirayr Tanielian – Hratch Tchilingirian – Yervand Yerkanian

Representative in Armenia

Artsvi Bakhchinyan

Table of Contents
Editorial An Armenological Repository

 

3
ARTICLES
Hranush Hakobyan Armenian identity issues   9
Vachagan Avagyan Water in Armenian Beliefs and Household Rites

 

43
Gayane Gevorgyan The Historical Development of the Structures of the Tense and Mood Systems in Armenian Dialects

 

57
Henrik Bakhchinyan The “Complaint” Poem by Frik

 

75
Ashot Manucharyan Theomachy in Armenia in the

XIII Century

 

89
Zaven Kniazian The “Dvin Violin”, A Medieval Musical Instrument from Armenia

 

103
Kristine Kostikyan

 

The Transformation of Armenian Monastery and Settlement Toponyms in Persian Documents

 

123
Arman Maloyan The role of Armenians in Ottoman Trade and the Number of the Armenians in Constantinople (1780-1820s)

 

153
Armen Hayrapetyan The Aragats  Chapter of the Social Democrat Hunchak Party (SDHP) in Alexandrapol, 1895-1904

 

173
Gegham Hovhannisyan The Hnchakyans during the 1917 Russian Revolution (February 1917-May 1918)

 

187
Gayane Makhmourian Nakhijevan in US State Department Documents and the National Archives of Armenia (1918-1920) 207
Father Nerses Asrian

 

Pages from the History of the closed diocese of Artsakh (1933-1988)

 

245
Zaven Messerlian Hamo Ohanjanian’s Letters to Gen. Casey and Tro Ganayan

 

277
Karine Rafaelyan

 

Survival and the Armenian Genocide Themes in Derenik Demirchyan’s Literary Works

 

301
Vacahagan Grigoryan Levon Shant’s Hin Asdvadzner (Old Gods) and the European Theater 325
Anush Aslibekyan

 

William Saroyan’s “Armenian Trilogy”

 

345
Grigor Arshakyan

 

Turkish-Armenian Relations in the Turkish Regional Politics Context (November 2002-August 2008, the Russo-Georgian Five-Day War) 367
Armenag Yeghiayan Words Spelt in More than One Way 395
INVESTIGATIVE ARTICLES
Parandzem Meytikhanian

 

The Translation of the Bible and Mesrop Mashtots’ Role

 

 

435
Tavit Kasbarian

 

Armenian Renaissance (Its Time and Characteristics)

 

441
Venera Makaryan  The Date When Catholicos Azaria Gargaretsi Establsihed His Rival Seat (17th-18th centuries) (According to the Sharia Court Register of Aleppo) 465
Karine Alexanian Denialism During the Turkish occupation of the District of Alexandropole (1918-1921)

 

473
Marina Moushegian

 

A Hundred-Year-Old Confusion: Komitas and His Dissertation on Kurdish Music

 

487
UNPUBLISHED DOCUMENTS
Haig Avakian

 

Letters of Arshag Chobanian and Levon Pashalian to Arpiar Arpiarian

 

499
Mihran Minasian

 

Unpublished Documents on the Condition of the Kilis Armenians During and After the 1909 Adana Massacres

 

515
Vartan  Matiossian

 

Newly-Discovered Letters Addressed to Hamasdegh 529
BRIEFINGS
Arsen Harutyunyan

 

Newly-Found Epigraphic Inscription from Tatev Monastery that Mentions the Name of St. Pandaleon (Pantaghion)

 

555
Norayr Poghosyan The Miracle of Patriarch Grigor Shghtayakir

 

 

573
Ani J. Avetisyan

 

Exhibitions Organized in Bursa Province and the Participation of Armenians 583
Arevik Meliqyan Nigol Mikayelian’s (aka Vana Ishkhan) Personal archive

 

607
Bedros Torosian Different Ways of Interpreting the Armenian Genocide 617
Susana Khachaturyan

 

 

The Armenian Arts Center in Tbilisi

 

627
Antranik Dakessian Additions to the List of the Volume of The Lebanese Armenian Book: A Bibliography, 1894-2012 635
BOOK REVIEWS
Ashod Krikorian

 

Yeghig Djerdjian, Metsen Murat (Hambartsum Poyadjian) 651
Arshag Boghosian Norayr Boghosian, Adventures in the History of Armenian Lexicography, Book I 655
Zohrab Kevorkian Vladimir Barkhutarian, Adventures in the History of Medieval Armenian Culture (X-XIV C.) 660
Yeva Zakarian Nevart Vartanian, Alvart Semirdjian-Bekmezian, Narine Vartanian, Contemporary Issues of Armenian Popular and Literary Fairy Tales 666
Vano Yegiazarian Henrik Bakhchinyan, The Book of Gandzes of Krikor Narekatsi: Decoding and Examination 671
Artsvi Bakhchinian С. А. Маркарян, Варяги-викинги на Кавказе (XI в.) [S. Margaryan, The Variags-Vikings in the Caucasus (XI C.) 679
NECROLOGY  
Mher Garabedyan (1939-2013), Margarita Yakhontova (1935-2014), Vladimir Ghazakhetsyan (1926-2015), Babken Harutyunian (1925-2015), Hagop Khachigian (1931–2015), Hrachig Simonian (1928-2016), Bedros Hovannissian  (1944-2016), John Greppin (1937–2016), Mardiros Minasian (1926-2016), Angel Kurkdjian (1927-2016), Anna Barsamian (1915-2016), Levon Yezekian (1941-2016), Hrachya Tamrazian (1953–2016), Hagop Ormandjian (1935-2016), Gabriella Uluhodjian (1934-2016), Parsegh Tughladjian (1933-2016)

 

685
Haigazian University
The Launching of the 36th Volume of the

Haigazian Armenological Review in Gyumri and Beirut

709
Note to Contributors 713
Table of Contents 719